Developing Scholarship Programs
A How-to Guide for CEWD Members
Scholarships can play a powerful role in building the future energy workforce. When thoughtfully designed, they do more than help students pay for education and training, they can expand access to high-quality career pathways, reduce barriers to completion, increase participation in occupations facing workforce shortages, and connect talented individuals to rewarding careers in the energy sector.
Cost is a common barrier, limiting both individuals’ access to rewarding careers and the sector’s access to the talent it needs.
One question runs through this guide: who is being kept out of energy careers today, and how can this program remove the barriers they face?
1. Plan
- Name the barriers and set goals. Ask community organizations, training providers, and students what stands in their way from getting started on a career in energy. Set measurable goals such as more applicants from underrepresented groups and/or higher completion rates.
- Choose your structure and funding. Decide whether to run the program in-house, through a community foundation, or with a third-party administrator. Budget for administration and plan beyond year one. Have counsel confirm your structure and tax reporting before launch.→ IRS: Company Scholarship Programs · IRS: Individual Grants (4945(g))
- Build eligibility around the barriers. Financial need, first-generation status, caregiving, geography, and veteran status are often more durable than criteria based on protected characteristics, and they reach many of the same learners. Have counsel review your criteria. Where your funding allows, open eligibility beyond a single service territory.
2. Design
- Blend need and merit, and weigh need heavily. Many programs incorporate both need- and merit-based criteria to achieve a combination of goals, i.e. supporting students with demonstrated financial need who may not otherwise pursue the targeted programs in energy, while also targeting students with strong academic foundations on which to succeed in the programs.→ Livehandbook review
- Target in-demand fields and programs with strong outcomes. Accreditation alone isn’t enough. Name eligible institutions and credentials, starting with schools you already partner with or hire from. Many private scholarships limit eligible programs to those at education institutions that are accredited. Relying only on accreditation as a proxy for quality is not a sufficient guardrail to ensure the scholarship investment is supporting students to pursue programs that would be a good use of their time, energy, and financial investment.→ Third Way · College Scorecard · TrainingProviderResults.gov · Energy employment trends · BLS workforce data
- Cover the full cost, not just tuition. Consider tools, workwear, certification fees, transportation, and living expenses, plus emergency aid for one-time costs. Many students face a gap between what they can afford and what it costs to pay for the education or workforce training program. Nontuition and fees expenses, such as housing, transportation, and food, are often significant drivers of this gap. Yet, many scholarships limit the awards to tuition, fees, books and supplies that are required to participate in the education or training program. Use first-dollar awards and check whether schools reduce aid when students receive private scholarships. Non-tuition amounts are generally taxable.→ IHEP on unmet need · IRS on taxability
- Make awards renewable and pair them with support. Renewable awards improve persistence, and advising, mentoring, and career exposure improve results further. There is a wide body of research that shows that financial aid is more effective when it is paired with support to help students overcome non-financial challenges that can derail progression in an education or training program.→ CUNY ASAP results
- Keep the application simple. Ask only what you need, make it work on a phone or tablet, and charge no fee.→ Harvard study on simplified aid applications
3. Administer
- Run a fair, transparent selection process. Publish your criteria, rubric, and timeline before applications open. Use an independent review committee, require conflict-of-interest disclosure and recusal, train reviewers on bias, and consider anonymizing early rounds.
- Make disbursement work for students and document it. Pay institutions directly for tuition after confirming enrollment and send living-expense funds straight to the student. Keep written procedures for approvals, withdrawals, unused funds, and records, and protect applicant data.
- Prioritize outreach to promote the scholarship application to communities and networks that could benefit from the scholarship program. Effective outreach can play an important role in ensuring scholarship opportunities reach individuals who may benefit most from the program but may not otherwise be aware of it.
4. Measure and Partner
- Measure results and adjust each cycle. Track applicants, awardees, renewals, completion, and employment by income, geography, and other characteristics to see whether you’re reaching the people you intended. Collect only the data you need.
- Pool resources and partner for outreach. The energy sector offers over 120 private scholarships with overlapping goals. Pooling lets a program make more awards, make them renewable, or add living-expense support. Partner with community organizations, workforce boards, schools, unions, and veterans’ organizations to reach the people who stand to benefit.→ Energy scholarships directory · Energy career pathways
